By David Keith | September 21, 2025

Supplementary comments on “A responsible way to cool the planet” with Zeke Hausfather, an opinion essay in the NYT published 21 September 2025.

My guess is that a fair-minded understanding of the risks and benefits of deploying a small amount (example below) of sunlight reflection would yield surprisingly broad support for limited deployment.

Yet, any talk of limited deployment comes with one giant caveat: the fear that once started, it would be politically hard to stop. If there’s a big problem, it’s easy to stop. But if it starts and goes roughly to plan, then there will be a strong temptation to keep doing more, while weakening efforts to cut emissions or remove carbon.

How to set up political structures that avoid over deployment? There are clever proposals for voting rules that tie the right to vote in decisions about SRM to successful emissions cuts, but there are no easy answers.

Zeke and I propose a simple rule: limit use of SRM to maintaining Earth’s reflectivity against the decrease in reflectivity that will continue as pollution is cleaned up. This rule has two useful consequences. First, it ties use of SRM to clean up of pollution, and since this pollution is mostly from burning fossil fuels, this is roughly equivalent to tying use of SRM to cuts in fossil fuels; and second, it provides a non-arbitrary fixed upper limit on how much SRM can be deployed.

One can imagine this rule is simple enough to be useful in international negotiation over sunlight reflection.

Any such limit can obviously be overridden. It’s impossible to bind the hands of the future, and it would be unwise to do so, even if it were possible.

 

Notes:

Here’s what a small amount could look like: injecting sulfur into the stratosphere using high-flying aircraft. Starting in the early 2030s and gradually increasing over time, the injection could, after about 50 years, reflect enough sunlight to cool Earth by 0.5 C. That would lower projected 2080 temperatures from about 2.5 C above pre-industrial levels without SRM to around 2.0 C, while balancing the cooling across both hemispheres. This a bit larger than current cooling now caused by pollution, which is more like 0.4 C, but it’s similar magnitude. The human and environmental benefits of reducing temperatures by half a degree are enormous as demonstrated by the IPCC 1.5 report.

A strong temptation to keep doing more. This is geoengineering’s moral hazard, perhaps better called “mitigation deterrence”. It can arise from political exploitation or collective addition, as I describe here: https://davidkeith.earth/publication/toward-constructive-disagreement-about-geoengineering-a-shared-taxonomy-of-concerns-may-help/ . It can arise from political exploitation or collective addition as I describe here: https://davidkeith.earth/publication/toward-constructive-disagreement-about-geoengineering-a-shared-taxonomy-of-concerns-may-help/

Here are my previous NYT op-eds:

The New York Times: What’s the Least Bad Way to Cool the Planet?

The New York Times: Blocking the Sky to Save the Earth

Related Content